Samantha Koon Jones, a prominent literary critic, has weighed in on Taylor Jenkins Reid's highly anticipated novel, "Atmosphere," a historical romance set against the backdrop of NASA's space shuttle program. While Jones acknowledges the book's initial captivating premise and engaging narrative, her review suggests the novel ultimately struggles to deliver a fulfilling conclusion.

"Atmosphere," promises readers a unique blend of romance and history, immersing them in the thrilling world of astronauts, engineers, and the dedicated individuals who propelled America's space program forward. Reid, known for her compelling characters and emotionally resonant storytelling, appears to have initially succeeded in capturing the excitement and challenges of this pivotal era. The novel likely delves into the intense training, the ever-present risks, and the unwavering dedication required to reach for the stars, all while exploring the complexities of love and relationships within this high-pressure environment.

Jones's review highlights the initial strength of Reid's storytelling. The book likely paints a vivid picture of the era, bringing the iconic space shuttles and the people behind them to life. Readers are likely drawn into the lives of the characters, becoming invested in their dreams, their fears, and their romantic entanglements. The combination of historical accuracy and emotional depth is typically a hallmark of Reid's work, and "Atmosphere" seemingly starts strong in this regard.

However, Jones's critique centers on the novel's ending, suggesting a lack of resolution or a departure from the satisfying conclusions Reid's readers have come to expect. The phrase "struggles to touch down" implies a sense of incompleteness, perhaps leaving readers with unanswered questions or a feeling that the characters' journeys haven't reached a satisfying destination. It raises the question of whether the narrative loses momentum in its final act, potentially sacrificing character development or plot resolution for the sake of a more ambiguous or unconventional ending. While some readers may appreciate such an approach, Jones's assessment suggests it ultimately detracts from the overall impact of the novel. Readers considering "Atmosphere" should therefore be aware that while the journey may be captivating, the destination, according to Jones, may leave something to be desired.