News
October 27, 2025
‘Regretting You’ review: Adaptation of Colleen Hoover novel a sappy affair
Early on, “Regretting You” pulls you into its tale of tragedy and betrayal. By the end, though, the adaptation of Colleen Hoover’s 2019 novel all but coats you in sap.
The film adaptation of Colleen Hoover's 2019 novel, "Regretting You," initially promises a compelling story of heartbreak and deception, but ultimately succumbs to an overabundance of sentimentality, leaving viewers saturated in melodrama. The movie, based on Hoover's popular book, starts strong, drawing audiences in with the potential for complex emotional exploration. However, as the narrative progresses, it veers away from nuanced storytelling and leans heavily into saccharine moments and predictable plot devices.
Early reviews suggest that the film captures the initial intrigue of the source material, hinting at a tale of family secrets, shattered trust, and the difficult journey of self-discovery. The premise, which revolves around unexpected tragedy and its ripple effects on the lives of the characters, undoubtedly holds significant dramatic weight. Viewers are initially engaged, eager to unravel the mysteries and empathize with the characters' struggles.
Unfortunately, the adaptation seems to struggle to maintain the delicate balance between genuine emotion and excessive sentimentality. Critics point to a reliance on overly dramatic scenes and dialogue that, while intended to evoke tears, ultimately feel forced and unearned. The film appears to prioritize emotional impact over narrative coherence, resulting in a viewing experience that feels manipulative rather than authentically moving.
While fans of Colleen Hoover's signature style might find some enjoyment in the film's heightened emotionality, those seeking a more sophisticated and nuanced portrayal of grief and betrayal may be left disappointed. The "sappy affair," as described by early reviewers, suggests that the film's potential is overshadowed by its reliance on overly sentimental tropes, ultimately diminishing the impact of what could have been a powerful and resonant story. The adaptation, it seems, favors dramatic flourish over subtle storytelling, leaving viewers with a lingering feeling of being emotionally manipulated rather than genuinely moved.
Early reviews suggest that the film captures the initial intrigue of the source material, hinting at a tale of family secrets, shattered trust, and the difficult journey of self-discovery. The premise, which revolves around unexpected tragedy and its ripple effects on the lives of the characters, undoubtedly holds significant dramatic weight. Viewers are initially engaged, eager to unravel the mysteries and empathize with the characters' struggles.
Unfortunately, the adaptation seems to struggle to maintain the delicate balance between genuine emotion and excessive sentimentality. Critics point to a reliance on overly dramatic scenes and dialogue that, while intended to evoke tears, ultimately feel forced and unearned. The film appears to prioritize emotional impact over narrative coherence, resulting in a viewing experience that feels manipulative rather than authentically moving.
While fans of Colleen Hoover's signature style might find some enjoyment in the film's heightened emotionality, those seeking a more sophisticated and nuanced portrayal of grief and betrayal may be left disappointed. The "sappy affair," as described by early reviewers, suggests that the film's potential is overshadowed by its reliance on overly sentimental tropes, ultimately diminishing the impact of what could have been a powerful and resonant story. The adaptation, it seems, favors dramatic flourish over subtle storytelling, leaving viewers with a lingering feeling of being emotionally manipulated rather than genuinely moved.
Category:
Entertainment